In 2022, Templeton Development paid $9.47 million for a Gulf-front homesite at 53 Sea Castle Alley in Alys Beach. They built a 5,124-square-foot spec home on it, finished it in 2025 and listed it at $31.25 million. In May 2026 it sold for $28 million, Mansion Global reported. 30A.com called it a community record. Get The Coast named A Boheme Design and Darrell Russell as the designers and Gulfview Construction as the builder.
Most coverage treats that sale as a headline number. For a buyer comparing Alys Beach with the rest of 30A, it's more useful as a picture of who sets prices in Alys Beach today. The developer has sold most of the land. More and more of what you can buy comes from owners reselling and from private builders who bought lots a few years ago and are now pricing finished homes. That changes what you pay and what you're choosing between.
The Developer's Count Barely Moved While Contracts Climbed
Each quarter, the Alys Beach sales team publishes the Alys Insider newsletter. Read in order, the 2026 issues show two different trends.
The first trend is contracts, and they rose fast. The Spring 2026 issue reported 19 contracts for $105,680,590 in the first quarter of 2026, up from 15 contracts for $74,205,000 in the first quarter of 2025. The Summer 2026 issue reported 40 contracts for $261,165,000 over the first two quarters of 2026. That is 54% more contracts and 74% more dollar volume than the first half of 2025. Subtracting the first quarter leaves 21 second-quarter contracts for about $155.5 million, an average of roughly $7.4 million each. The first-quarter average was about $5.56 million. As of June 20, the newsletter counted seven 2026 sales between $7 million and $10 million and seven above $10 million.
The second trend is the developer's own tally of properties sold, and it barely changed. The Spring issue listed 568 properties sold, 452 completed residences, 113 under construction and about 216 in remaining inventory. In the Summer issue the tally was 570 sold, 452 completed and 115 under construction. The Fall 2026 issue put the share of planned properties sold at 73% as of October 1, 2026. It also reported that all real estate sales through the third quarter of 2026 were 46% above 2025.
So the developer's count went up by two between the spring and summer issues, while the second quarter alone produced 21 contracts. The Fall issue frames its growth figure as all real estate sales, and the gap between that pace and a nearly flat count of properties sold points to owners reselling as the source of most of 2026's increase. Two other figures fit that reading. In the summer count, 452 completed homes plus 115 under construction comes to 567, close to the 570 sold, so almost every lot the developer has sold is built or being built. The remaining inventory of about 216 is what keeps the percentage sold in the low 70s.
Who Sets the Price When the Land Is Mostly Spoken For
When few new lots come to market, the people who already hold lots decide what a finished home costs. Spec builders are the clearest case.
Measured by Gulf frontage, the Sea Castle Alley homesite cost about $179,000 per foot in 2022, based on the 53 feet of frontage Mansion Global reported. On August 1, 2025, a different Gulf-front homesite with 43 feet of frontage closed at $15.5 million for a planned custom home, according to a developer announcement reposted on SoWal. The announcement called it a record price per Gulf-front foot. That is about $360,000 per foot, roughly double the 2022 figure in three years, and it's for land alone.
The finished house followed the same pattern. Brad Dahler of Scenic Sotheby's International Realty, the listing agent, told Mansion Global that the Templetons "had the foresight to see where the market was headed based on previous transactions in Alys Beach." The $28 million price works out to about $5,465 per square foot. In the same Mansion Global article, Dahler noted that no Alys Beach house has its own walkover to the sand. Owners reach the beach through community property such as the Beach Club. At that price, a Gulf-front buyer is paying for the frontage, the view and the finished house. Beach access is the same for every owner.
Asking Prices by the Square Foot, From the Developer's Own Newsletter
Below the Gulf-front tier, the clearest comparison comes from the listings featured in the three 2026 newsletters. These are asking prices from the date of each issue, not closed sales, and some homes may have sold since.
| Property | Issue | Description in newsletter | Asking price | Sq. ft. | Ask per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 117 Elbow Beach Road | Fall 2026 | Newly constructed, Gary Justiss Architect | $11,295,000 | 4,378 | about $2,580 |
| 185 Elbow Beach Road | Fall 2026 | Newly constructed, Chancey Design | $14,615,000 | 5,910 | about $2,473 |
| 26 Sea Garden Street | Spring 2026 | New construction, Chancey Architecture, built by Arkon | $10,350,000 | 4,310 | about $2,401 |
| 24 Kings Castle Court | Summer 2026 | Khoury Vogt Architects | $7,700,000 | 3,470 | about $2,219 |
| 195 North Charles Street | Fall 2026 | Christ & Associates Architects | $8,875,000 | 4,415 | about $2,010 |
| 50 North Sea Garden Street | Summer 2026 | Khoury Vogt Architects, Alys Beach Construction | $5,150,000 | 2,868 | about $1,796 |
| 57 Sugar Loaf Alley | Spring 2026 | Custom residence on an endcap homesite | $6,095,000 | 3,436 | about $1,774 |
| Varian 303 | Summer 2026 | Town Center condominium | $4,951,431 | 1,977 | about $2,504 |
| Whitby 304 | Spring 2026 | Town Center condominium | $3,550,000 | 1,878 | about $1,890 |
The three homes the newsletters describe as new construction all ask between about $2,400 and $2,580 a foot. The other single-family homes in the table ask between about $1,775 and $2,220. On a 4,400-square-foot house, the gap between those two bands comes to anywhere from about $800,000 to $3.5 million, depending on which homes you compare. The premium buys a finished house you can use right away. The newsletter copy shows what that looks like: 185 Elbow Beach Road comes fully furnished with an elevator and a shared rooftop terrace with Gulf views. 26 Sea Garden Street comes with first-floor furnishings by Chancey Interior Design.
The two condominiums are far apart on price per foot. Whitby 304 overlooks the Amphitheatre and Town Center. Varian 303 asks about 32% more per foot. A condo also costs less in total than any house in the table, but that alone doesn't make it the cheaper way into Alys Beach per square foot.
Where Developer Inventory Still Exists
The developer hasn't stopped selling. The Summer issue described current inventory as custom homes, luxury rowhomes and Town Center condominium residences, with "many opportunities for purchase to deliver over the next several years." The Fall issue said the sales team is in design charrettes for several new developments in Alys Beach. If those developments add properties to the plan, the denominator grows. That would explain why the percentage sold has stayed in the 73% to 74% range across all three issues even as sales picked up.
The developer credits the demand to Town Center. The Summer issue tied the rise in prices to the growth of Town Center and the July 2 opening of Indaco. The Fall issue reported summer rental revenue up nearly 9% over summer 2025. It also said Rowan and an expanded KREWE location are coming to The Liner building this fall. For an owner who plans to rent, those are the developer's own figures on the demand behind its pricing. Our earlier post on the season Alys Beach finished building covers how the Town Center roster came together.
Three Ways In, and What Each One Costs
Taken together, these figures give a buyer in late 2026 three distinct ways into Alys Beach.
The first is an existing home. In the newsletters, this is the lowest asking price per foot for a single-family house, roughly $1,775 to $2,220. Because owners now drive most of the sales activity, this is also where most of the choice is. Location within town matters as much as the house: 57 Sugar Loaf Alley, for example, is described as steps from Caliza Pool and overlooking Arboleda Park.
The second is a newly finished home from a builder, at roughly $2,400 to $2,600 a foot in the 2026 newsletters. The premium pays for a house that is already standing, often furnished, as 185 Elbow Beach Road is.
The third is a homesite with a custom build. You keep control of the design and take on the land price and the timeline. On the Gulf, the August 2025 sale puts that land price at about $360,000 per foot of frontage before construction starts. Off the Gulf, any new homesites will come from developments the developer hasn't yet released.
In all three, the developer is no longer the main seller in Alys Beach. Prices this year came from owners deciding when to sell and from builders deciding what a finished house is worth. Before writing an offer, it helps to compare the asking price with recent closed sales, using the 30A Market Snapshot and our Alys Beach neighborhood guide. The architecture guide for design lovers covers how the town's design standards shape every one of these homes.
If you're deciding between an Alys Beach home that's already lived in and one that's just finished, The Richards Group can compare the asking price per foot against what has actually closed nearby and help you decide which premium is worth paying. Connect with Allison Richards to talk through the options.